“I don’t believe in God, but I miss him.”
Julian Barnes’ Nothing to Be Frightened Of explores how we, the living and not of formal faith, respond to death. It continually captures that multiplicity of the human relationship with faith, our contradictions, inspirations and hypocrisies.
A couple of months ago I reviewed on Facebook Julian Barnes’ recently published, last ever book, Departure(s), and received three responses: I find him ‘bleak’, ‘will try’ and a clapping emoji. I think Barnes would have appreciated the sparseness of that trio, given his honest portrayals of life. He mentioned this book on death in passing, and I immediately thought, that’s a book I want to read, which leads us here to this review.
I read Nothing to Be Frightened Of in small bites at a time, and delighted, again, in his intelligence and polymath ability to shed light on death and dying. I especially appreciated his giving voice to a constituency of people who are not well covered in terms of death culture. These are the increasingly numerous, on the agnostic to atheist spectrum. If you have a therapeutic worldview, they are probably within us as internal parts. Barnes talks of one of his parents being atheist, the other agnostic, and he straddles this divide in the book: the rationalist and the somewhat believer.
I remember saying to Mum, “We’re atheists, aren’t we?”, having never gone to church as a child. I was met with an indignant, if not upset, reply: “No, we’re Evangelisch” (the German for Protestant). It took me till my thirties to realise I was baptised, in a cathedral no less. Later I emerged as a theist and found my home in the spiritual community of Findhorn in my twenties. Yet that world of the spiritual both interweaves with and separates from religion.
As my mother’s response also indicated, no religious activity does not mean atheism.
The somewhat believers
This ‘somewhat believing’ grouping (perhaps a more financially oriented person would call them a market) was who the interfaith ministry training was aimed at: those who were not of a faith and who wished for the power of a ceremonial rite of passage. Here in Australia, the civil celebrancy movement, which now celebrates 84% of all weddings, was set up in 1971 to support those wishing (needing, I do believe) for an authentic ceremony outside of religion.
So a tribe, a grouping of sorts, of some type of believers, including non-believers, who never or rarely go to church (insert mosque, synagogue or temple as fits your own ancestry). Yet Christmas is celebrated, Easter eggs are bought, Gregorian chants are hummed to, and at times of rites of passage a moment comes where that choice is needed: how can we best honour this moment, whether a funeral, a wedding or another threshold?
Barnes covers this multiplicity of the secular and the touched by something higher. He writes of jealousy of those of faith as he ages, of the sureness of a religious orientation as death knocks on the door, and how, as age dilutes the righteousness of youth, profound existential questions remain.
Is it possible to be touched by the beauty of religious art and music whilst not being religious? Barnes weaves Stendhal’s story through the book, and his eponymous syndrome of those who faint at the beauty of Florence’s artworks, and then unravels the story as far more complicated than a simple binary reality of atheist and believer, as perhaps fits someone with two names, as Stendhal/Beyle had.

Dying or death?
Barnes meanders over many facets of death, illustrating them with historical anecdotes, often from French literary culture. What do we fear more, dying or death? He quotes the British theatre director Jonathan Miller agreeing with Freud that he “cannot actually conceive, can’t make sense of the notion of total annihilation”. Or how Arthur Koestler, on a literal death row in the Spanish Civil War, never expected to die there (and didn’t, another of the fascinating stories within the story). Is it possible, when alive, to conceive of the ending of life?
Do we live differently when we, like the Tibetan Buddhists, see the importance of death? You’d hope so, yet we live in a death-averse culture, and it’s immensely tempting, if not humanly instinctive, to kick the can down the road.
I’ve just moved to Australia after five years in rural India, where death was seen and heard. Local villagers would stop en masse, and grief was loud with drums, trumpets and wailing, and public. A funeral cortège would walk through the high street, or even along the motorway, leaving a bright path of marigolds, and corpses were seen by all, from young children to those next in line to the burning pyres. Here in Australia, as in the UK, death is far away again, neat and tidied up, referred to, if at all, in allusion: ‘passing away’.
This pushing of death to the underside of the carpet is a recent change. As Barnes notes, “not so long ago, the dying would have spent their final illness at home, expired among family, been washed and laid out by local women, watched over companionably for a night or two, then coffined up by the local undertaker.”
Barnes has a particular honesty in how he writes, a lack of inflation and a dry wit that pops in at times. The over-medicalisation of death and of pain is touched on, and there is plenty on his family in their particularness, which reminded me of my own particularness and of my family’s.
What the book leaves out
He doesn’t cover some of the new ways of acknowledging death without religion: the interfaith work some of us have been trained in for just this grouping of people, the Buddhist viewpoints of death, or the value of secular ceremony that the Australian civil celebrant movement has worked on, with varying degrees of success.
There is a value, I believe, to ceremony that can be life-changing, and that isn’t covered.
But that is no detraction from the book, as it brought to life my origins and social circles, and explored how the agnostic and atheist life meets death. Death always elicits deep questions: of the power of the sacred, of the need for rites or ceremony, of existential doubts and fears. A funeral is a moment where life is revealed in its starkness, its best and its reality.
After my last Facebook post I won’t recommend the book, but I do recommend the message: of being more aware of our inevitable death, of its immediate companion, denial, and of how it brings a long view, perspective and value (oh, unexpected irony) to life.

If you are thinking about a funeral or memorial, for someone you love or for yourself, you can read about how I work here: Funerals →
